Literature โ€” Literary Criticism

Dr Samuel Johnson

Study notes, literary analysis, key themes, and exam questions on Dr Samuel Johnson for UP TGT & PGT English.

UP PGT English UP TGT English B.A. / M.A. Level

Dr Samuel Johnson (1709โ€“1784), often referred to simply as Dr Johnson, was a towering figure of 18th-century English literatureโ€”a poet, essayist, moralist, literary critic, biographer, and lexicographer. As the quintessential representative of the Age of Sensibility and the Augustan transition, Johnson shaped English letters through monumental achievements like 'A Dictionary of the English Language' (1755), his critical prefaces in 'Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets' (1779โ€“1781), and his edition of the plays of William Shakespeare. For UP TGT/PGT and UGC-NET aspirants, Johnson's biographical positioning by James Boswell, his neoclassic aesthetic preferences, his moral conservatism, and his critique of poetic diction are vital core areas frequently tested.

1. Lexicography and the Monumental Dictionary

Standardization of the English language through empirical citation and prescriptive lexicography.

  • Took nine years (1746โ€“1755) to compile A Dictionary of the English Language single-handedly with minimal secretarial help.
  • Included 42,773 entries with extensive illustrative literary quotations drawn from authors spanning the Elizabethan era to the 18th century.
  • Featured iconic, often idiosyncratic definitions reflecting Johnson's robust Tory politics, robust common sense, and wit (e.g., 'Oats: A grain, which in England is generally given to horses, but in Scotland supports the people').
  • Initially hoped to fix the English language and arrest its corruption, though he later conceded in the 1755 Preface that language is inherently organic and subject to change ('languages are not invariants, they are like leaves on trees').
  • Dedicated the Dictionary initially to Lord Chesterfield, later castigating him in a famous 1755 letter for patronage neglect ('Is a patron, my Lord, one who looks with unconcern on a man struggling for life in the water...').
Comparative Analysis: Contrasts with modern descriptive lexicography (like the Oxford English Dictionary) which records usage rather than prescribing a normative standard.
  • Published in 1755, establishing British English spelling and usage norms.
  • Marked a massive leap forward from previous glossaries by using contextual literary citations.

2. Literary Criticism and Shakespearean Scholarship

Neoclassical critical principles balanced by empirical moralism and psychological realism.

  • The Preface to Shakespeare (1765) defends Shakespeare against strict French neoclassical rules of the Unities (Time and Place), arguing that the mind easily bridges spatial and temporal gaps in dramatic illusion.
  • Famous critical dictum on Shakespeare: 'He that accuses him of wanting heart, has himself no heart.'
  • Critiqued Shakespeare's moral laxity ('he sacrifices virtue to convenience') and his occasional descent into 'fatal Cleopatra' puns and conceits.
  • Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets (commonly known as Lives of the Poets, 1779โ€“1781) covers 52 poets from Cowley to Lyttelton.
  • Famous controversial critiques within Lives include his harsh dismissal of John Milton's Lycidas ('easy, vulgar, and therefore disgusting') and his censure of metaphysical conceits in Abraham Cowley and John Donne.
Comparative Analysis: Compares with Matthew Arnold's 'touchstone method' and John Dryden's neoclassical critical prefaces.
  • Defended dramatic verisimilitude over pedantic adherence to Aristotle's unities of time and place.
  • Established biographical-critical evaluation as a dominant paradigm in English literary criticism.

3. Major Non-Fictional Prose and Periodical Essays

Moralistic periodical essays upholding Augustan rationality, Christian stoicism, and human limitation.

  • The Rambler (1750โ€“1752): A twice-weekly periodical essay series characterized by heavy, Latinate prose style ('Johnsonese') and deep moral seriousness.
  • The Idler (1758โ€“1760): Lighter, more varied periodical essays published in the Universal Chronicle.
  • The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia (1759): A philosophical fable written in evenings over one week to pay for his mother's funeral; explores the universal 'choice of life' and the vanity of human wishes.
  • The Vanity of Human Wishes (1749): Johnson's masterly imitation of Juvenal's Satire X, reflecting on the futility of ambition across historical figures (Wolsey, Charles XII of Sweden).
  • Rambler No. 4: A foundational text of early English literary realism and the novel, warning against depicting unrealistic moral extremes in fiction.
Comparative Analysis: Mirrors the earlier journalistic successes of Joseph Addison and Richard Steele in The Spectator, but with a darker, more melancholic Christian-stoic depth.
  • Rasselas emphasizes that human happiness is an illusion and true fulfillment is found only in the afterlife.
  • The Vanity of Human Wishes is hailed by critics like T.S. Eliot as a supreme masterpiece of poetic satire.

4. Biography, Boswell, and Cultural Persona

The transition of Johnson from literary author to immortalized literary icon through James Boswell's biography.

  • James Boswell published 'The Life of Samuel Johnson' in 1791, widely considered the greatest biography in the English language.
  • Captured Johnson's idiosyncratic physical traits, conversational brilliance, Tory-Jacobite sympathies, profound religious melancholy, and deep humanitarianism.
  • Formed 'The Club' (later Literary Club) in 1764 with Joshua Reynolds, Edmund Burke, Oliver Goldsmith, and David Garrick.
  • Celebrated journey to the Western Islands of Scotland (1773), chronicled both by Johnson (A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland) and Boswell (Journal of a Tour to the Hebrides).
  • Affectionately dubbed 'The Great Cham of Literature' by Tobias Smollett.
Comparative Analysis: Contrasts standard hagiographic biographies with Boswell's psychologically intimate, warts-and-all observational technique.
  • Boswell's biography immortalized Johnson's conversational persona far beyond his written works.
  • Brought unprecedented empirical detail and personal anecdote into the biographical genre.

Literary Periods & Regional Context

๐ŸŒ Global/Historical Context

Belongs firmly to the Augustan Age / Age of Sensibility (mid-to-late 18th century in Britain). Stood against the rising tide of early Romantic individualism, defending universal human nature, decorum, and classical models.

๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ Indian Literature in English

Crucial part of the British Literature core syllabus across all Indian universities (BA, MA, UGC-NET) and UP TGT/PGT English examinations, serving as the benchmark for 18th-century neoclassicism.

๐Ÿ“ Key Literary Devices & Grammar Rules
Heroic Couplet (Johnsonian Versification)
AABB... iambic pentameter rhymed couplets with strong caesura and balanced antithesis.
Parameters: Meter: Strict iambic pentameter; Structure: Closed couplets containing complete grammatical thoughts; Rhetorical devices: Antithesis, parallel structure, balance.
Exam Focus: Frequently tested in questions regarding The Vanity of Human Wishes and Johnson's mastery of closed neoclassical verse forms.
Neoclassical Critical Evaluation Model
Empirical Observation + Moral Utility + Universal Human Nature = Canonical Standing
Parameters: Evaluation criteria prioritizing verisimilitude, moral instruction, general human truths over local eccentricities, and rejection of extravagant conceits.
Exam Focus: Essential framework for answering analytical questions on Preface to Shakespeare and Lives of the Poets in UGC-NET and PGT.

Mnemonics, Memory Shortcuts & Exam Traps

๐Ÿ’ก J-R-L-P: Major Works of Dr Samuel Johnson
J - R - L - P

J = Dictionary (Johnson's/Journal); R = Rasselas; L = Lives of the Poets; P = Preface to Shakespeare.

โš ๏ธ Exam Trap: Candidates often confuse the publication year of the Dictionary (1755) with Rasselas (1759) and Preface to Shakespeare (1765). Memorize the chronological gap of 10 years from Dictionary to Shakespeare.
๐Ÿ’ก Periodical Essay Distinctions
Rambler = Hard / Idler = Idle

The Rambler (1750-52) uses heavy Latinate prose ('Johnsonese') and deep moral rigor. The Idler (1758-60) is lighter, more satirical, and relaxed.

โš ๏ธ Exam Trap: Do not mistake Johnson's periodicals with Addison & Steele's The Spectator or The Tatler; always verify the author and exact dates.